Thursday 15 November 2007

Punkupine

With Boyzone joining the Spice Girls and Take That on tour the most commonly leveled criticism is that these are manufactured music groups. It has to be remembered that manufactured doesn't always mean bad. Malcolm McLaren manufactured the Sex Pistols after all. Actually they've just announced a tour as well.

The main reason most of this kind of bad have a bad reputation is because they are rubbish. But some manufacture bands can create great music:



5 comments:

Joe said...

I hate the "manufactured" argument. There are thousands of shite indie bands around, for example, and plenty of people who don't perform but write cracking tunes for their muses.

Let's face it - which of the two is better?

a) The fucking awful America by Razorlight
b) The fucking amazing No Good Advice by Girls Aloud

No contest.

Joe said...

Alex you can tick the "Response from Joe" box now :)

fourstar71 said...

Girls Aloud r t3h b0mbz0Rrz!!!111

fourstar71 said...

Ahem, apparently what I meant to say was that Xenomania appear to be an awfully good team of songwriters and that I don't fancy Nadine at all.

(Will this do? - Marriage Ed)

Alex Andronov said...

It's all the Beatles fault innit?

On the other hand I do fear the excesses of "manufactured" at the other end.

I love Cathy Dennis when she writes Toxic for Britney, but remember she also sings the growl at the end of the Pop Idol music. It's double edged...